{Mascara} The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly

mascara, the good the bad and the ugly, beauty tips

So, I’m a sucker for mascaras. I’ll try them all. Cheap, expensive, waterproof, fiber. I’m a girl that doesn’t have to have eyeliner or foundation on when I leave the house, but I always have my mascara. These past 6 months I have tried 5 different mascaras and found that some of them are worth the money, and some of them not so much. One of them I even hated so much that I used it twice and ended up throwing it away. It was really that bad.

So here you have it…The good, The bad, and The ugly of Mascaras.

Let’s start with one of the “goods”, which has always been a personal favorite of mine.

Benefit Roller Lash Mascara

This one is an expert at curling and lengthening the lashes, which has a lot to do with the hook n’ roll brush. The curved brush tip works wonders when it comes to curling and separating. Add two coats of it and you’re adding lots of length to your lashes as well. Out of all of the mascaras I’ve tried these past several months this one definitely looks and feels the most natural. My lashes don’t feel weighed down, and they’re soft to the touch. It washes off easily with your cleanser, which is nice because it doesn’t require an eye makeup remover like some of the other mascaras.

Retails for $24.

Finished look of the Roller Lash Mascara

benefit roller lash mascara


Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara

Another “good” one is the classic beauty blogger fave, Too Faced’s Better Than Sex Mascara. I’ve heard bloggers talking about this one for a very long time, and this technically wasn’t my first time to try it. I have to say it isn’t my absolute favorite, but I see what the hype is about. It adds a lot of thickness to the lashes, which is nice for someone like me with very thin natural lashes. What I don’t like about it is that you have to be careful applying it or it will clump up quite a bit. It seems to take me longer to apply, so I only use it sometimes. It doesn’t wash off super easily with just your cleanser, so you have to use an eye makeup remover when taking it off.

Retails for $23.

Finished look of the Better Than Sex Mascara

too faced better than sex mascara


Younique Moodstruck 3D Fiber Lashes

When I first started using this mascara I had very mixed feelings about it. I kept seeing pictures of people who had used it and their lashes looked pretty awesome, and mine just seemed to look ugly. I kept using it, though, and I’m glad that I stuck it out because it works pretty awesome when you figure out how to use it properly! It’s a little tricky at first. There’s a transplant mascara that you apply OVER a different mascara (I used Roller Lash as my base), then you apply the fibers, and then REAPPLY the transplant mascara over the fibers. See? Tricky. But I really like the way it lengthens and thickens my lashes. It gives lashes the look of false strip lashes without fussing with the glue and application. This does not come off with your cleanser, so eye makeup remover is required for removal.

Retails for $29.

Finished look of the Moodstruck 3D Fiber Lashes

younique moodstruck 3d fiber lash mascara


Wondering which mascara is the “bad” one? It’s seriously the worst mascara I’ve ever tried….it’s

Revlon Ultimate All-In-One Mascara

Revlon claims that it’s going to lengthen, add volume and definition, lift, and add intense color. It literally did none of these things for me. This drug store mascara is only $6 but I wouldn’t waste my money on it again. I used it twice and then threw it away because it wasn’t even good enough to just finish the tube and move on. I definitely think there are way better mascaras that are priced about the same as the Revlon All-In-One. Don’t even waste your time or efforts on this one.

Retails for $6.

Finished look of the Revlon All-In-One Mascara.

revlon all-in-one mascara


Mary Kay Lash Intensity Mascara

My cousin is a Mary Kay Consultant and sent me a sample of the Lash Intensity Mascara a few months ago, and let me tell you, it quickly rose to the top of my favorite mascara list! It’s amazing! My lashes look so full, long, and dark all while staying very smooth and natural feeling. I am starting to really love Mary Kay products! Not very long ago I tried a charcoal mask from Mary Kay and was so impressed! (You can find my review here.) The mascara is easy to apply because it looks good even with just one coat.  If you want to check it out or have questions about the product, contact my girl Audrey Parnell. It’s definitely worth the money, in my opinion. I think I’ve found my new go-to mascara!

Retails for $18.

Finished look of the Lash Intensity Mascara.

Mary Kay Lash Intensity mascara

What’s your all time favorite mascara? Leave it in the comments below!

Don’t forget to sign up at the bottom of the page for BrownEyedAndBlushing email updates!

6 thoughts on “{Mascara} The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly

  1. I have tried all those but the moonstruck 3D. I was looking for a good water proof mascara and went to the mall and waisted a lot of money😞🤦🏻‍♀️ the better than sex one was the worst for me 😩 🤷🏻‍♀️ it flaked a lot after time👎🏻 I found a drug store mascara that I love more then even the benefit, witch used to be my favorite but it was not waterproof.. this new one I have is called Voluminous Lash Paradise waterproof version and I love it makes them thick and long and it’s very waterproof. I can swim all day in it and no smearing or ratcoon eyes. I’m so excited becuase it only retails for 7.00 at any drugstore it’s my new go to 💯👌🏻


  2. Thanks for the info, it was interesting!
    I’m searching for a great mascara that doesn’t smudge under my eyes, that is also a healthy formula…so far…it’s not to be found 😦


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: